3 Signs Your Old Filling Needs a Refresh

November 20, 2025

Q: How do I know if my dental filling needs to be replaced?
A: Signs include tooth sensitivity, cracks or chips, and dark edges around the filling. A quick dental exam can confirm if it’s time for a composite replacement.

If you feel discomfort when eating hot, cold, or sweet foods, your old filling may be leaking or separating from the tooth surface.


When that happens, bacteria can sneak in and cause decay under the filling—something you won’t see, but your dentist will detect during an exam.


Solution: Schedule a quick evaluation. Replacing the filling early prevents deeper decay and saves the tooth from needing more complex treatment later.

Cracks, Chips, or Worn Edges

Over time, fillings naturally wear down or crack under pressure from chewing or teeth grinding.


You may even feel a 
rough edge with your tongue. These damaged spots can allow bacteria to enter and cause hidden cavities beneath the surface.


Solution: A simple composite filling replacement restores the tooth’s strength and smooth surface—no metal, just a seamless finish that looks and feels natural.

dental filling check up with Dr Colleen Catera DMD

Staining or Dark Lines Around the Filling

If you notice discoloration, dark edges, or staining around an old filling, it may mean that the seal has weakened or new decay has formed nearby.


Older silver (amalgam) fillings are especially prone to this issue, but even composite fillings can lose their bond over time.


Solution: Replacing it with a new composite filling refreshes your smile, strengthens the tooth, and prevents decay from spreading.


Visit our Composite Dental Restorations page to see how natural and long-lasting these restorations can be.

Why Choose Composite Fillings

Composite fillings are durable, safe, and blend perfectly with your natural teeth.


Benefits include:

  • Tooth-colored finish for a natural look
  • Strong bonding that supports the tooth
  • Less drilling than traditional fillings
  • Long-lasting results with proper care



At Dr. Catera’s office, we use high-quality composite materials designed to restore your smile beautifully and comfortably.

composite dental fillings Babylon New York

Schedule a Dental Checkup in Babylon, NY

If you’ve noticed sensitivity, cracks, or staining around your old filling, don’t wait for it to worsen.


A quick dental exam can confirm whether your filling just needs a touch-up or a full replacement.


At Dr. Colleen L. Catera, DMD, we’re passionate about educating our patients and making every visit comfortable and stress-free.


Our preventive and restorative care ensures your smile stays healthy for years to come.


📍 Dr. Colleen L. Catera, DMD: 1 John St, Suite 206, Babylon, NY 11702
📞
(631) 422-6901
🌐 
Schedule an Appointment

  • How long do dental fillings last?

    Composite fillings typically last 7–10 years but may wear faster with heavy chewing or grinding.

  • Can I replace a metal filling with a composite one?

    Yes! Many patients choose to replace silver fillings with natural-looking composites for a cleaner, healthier appearance.

  • What happens if I ignore a cracked or loose filling?

    Ignoring it can lead to decay, infection, or even the need for a root canal. It’s best to have it checked early.

Ready To Start Smiling?

Call (631) 422-6901 Today


Digital dental X-ray technology at a Babylon NY dental office
By Dr Colleen L Catera DMD December 12, 2025
Are dental X-rays safe? Learn the facts vs myths about digital dental X-rays, radiation exposure, and modern imaging from a Babylon NY dentist.
dentist performing gum health exam for periodontal disease in Babylon NY
By Dr Colleen L. Catera DMD December 2, 2025
Learn ADA-recognized early signs of gum disease and when to schedule a gum health check with Dr. Catera in Babylon, NY.
zoom office whitening procedure in Babylon NY dental office
By Dr Colleen L Catera DMD November 14, 2025
Learn what to expect during Zoom office whitening at Dr. Catera’s Babylon, NY dental practice. Fast, safe, same-day whitening with professional results.
root canal treatment procedure in Babylon NY dental office
By Dr Colleen L Catera DMD November 6, 2025
Think root canals are painful? Think again. Learn the facts from Dr. Colleen L. Catera, DMD—your trusted Babylon dentist in Babylon, New York.
patient gum exam and periodontal health check in Babylon NY
Internal Links:
By Dr Colleen L Catera DMD October 30, 2025
Learn the early signs of periodontal (gum) disease and when to see Dr. Catera in Babylon for gentle, preventive dental care.
Porcelain dental crown being placed by Dr. Colleen Catera in Babylon NY
By Dr Colleen L. Catera DMD October 16, 2025
Discover the different types of dental crowns and find out which one may be best for your smile. Serving patients in Babylon and across Long Island.
How often should you replace your toothbrush
By Dr Colleen L. Catera DMD October 9, 2025
Learn how often you should replace your toothbrush and why it matters for your oral health. Tips from Dr. Colleen L. Catera, DMD in Babylon, NY.
Patient who is nervous about a dental appointment due to dental anxiety.
By Dr Colleen L. Catera DMD September 25, 2025
Dental anxiety is common, but it doesn’t have to stop you from a healthy smile. Learn calming tips and how Dr. Colleen Catera in Babylon helps patients feel at ease.
Dentist showing patient tooth replacement options for missing teeth
By Dr Colleen Catera DMD September 18, 2025
Missing teeth affect more than your smile—they impact health, confidence, and bone structure. Learn why timely tooth replacement is essential.
Dentist explaining the benefits of fluoride for strong and healthy teeth
By Dr Colleen L Catera DMD September 12, 2025
Discover how fluoride strengthens enamel, prevents cavities, and protects your smile. Learn why fluoride treatments are recommended by Dr. Colleen Catera in Babylon, NY.
Show More